Insurance Claim Denied Due to Undisclosed Conviction

2

Holding a motor insurance policy covering a fleet of three trucks under his company, a director submitted a claim when one of the vehicles suffered fire damage. However, due diligence performed by Zurich Australia unveiled that the director had a criminal traffic conviction on record dating back to March 2021 that was not previously disclosed.

The insurance company took the position that this omitted information was pivotal and declared that it would have otherwise refrained from underwriting the policy. The director's defense rested on the claim that he perceived the incident not as a criminal offense but rather a trivial issue, describing the non-disclosure as unintentional.

Nevertheless, the Australian Financial Complaints Authority (AFCA) emphasized that the director faced pointed questions upon the insurance policy's inception that should have signaled the need for divulgence of the conviction. The adjudicator from AFCA concluded that the director, or any prudent individual in a similar position, ought to have recognized the importance of such information to the insurer's risk assessment.

The reported incident draws attention to a 'relevant failure' under the Insurance Contracts Act 1984, with Zurich within its rights to narrow its liability and proceed with the policy's annulment. The AFCA adjudician expressed that obliging the insurer to settle the claim under these circumstances would be unjust.

In the aftermath, the insurance company is required to return the paid premiums post cancellation of the policy to the policyholder along with accrued interest - a measure to settle the books between the parties involved.

This situation signals to policyholders the vital necessity of full transparency when acquiring insurance coverage. Insurance applicants and holders should be aware that nondisclosure, even unintended, can have significant consequences, impacting both the validity of claims and the standing of policies.

Published:Thursday, 2nd May 2024
Source: Paige Estritori

Share this news item:

Insurance News

Senate Probes Climate's Toll on Insurance Costs and Access 18 May 2024: Paige Estritori The Senate has launched an investigation into the growing climate risks that are affecting insurance premiums, with a focus on affordability and accessibility. - read more

Adviser Shortage and Policy Shifts Impact Life/Risk Market 17 May 2024: Paige Estritori The decline of life/risk advisers paired with the Australian Prudential Regulation Authority's (APRA's) intervention in the Individual Disability Income (IDII) insurance sector imposes fresh challenges on the market, hinting at recovery only intermittently. - read more

Insurers Under Fire: Melbourne Floods Reveal Gaps and Mismatches 16 May 2024: Paige Estritori Residents from western Melbourne have voiced sharp disapproval of insurance companies at the recent federal inquiry hearings held in Maribyrnong, citing significant grievances post the 2022 floods. - read more

Allianz Streamlines Flood Insurance with New Update 16 May 2024: Paige Estritori Allianz has taken a considerable step forward in modifying its flood insurance approach for homeowners. Drawing conclusions from the flood incidents of 2022, changes are set to be implemented to provide clearer and more inclusive coverage. As a measure to simplify their insurance products, Allianz will integrate flood insurance as a non-negotiable component of home building, contents, and landlord policies for new clients starting from the latter part of this year. - read more

Australian Tourist Secures Compensation for Air Ambulance From Bangkok 11 May 2024: Paige Estritori A recent decision by a dispute resolution body in favor of a 74-year-old Australian traveler has emphasized the importance of clear communication and precise terms and conditions in insurance policies. This comes after the individual engaged in a tug-of-war with an insurance company over a $195,223 claim to cover emergency medical transportation from Thailand. - read more